Then this evening he was working intently on something while Omi and I were making dinner. This is what he came up with (the masking taped used to correct errors):
(in case you are puzzled: "I wish I had a dog.")
Again he asked if it was right. I said it was fantastic and a great sentence and very good writing, and that he was just missing an A and a D. He then tried again... and again... and again... and kept getting stuck on various bits, especially the repeated "A-D-A-D" (which makes sense as a place to get stuck). He was ENORMOUSLY frustrated. There were tears. He refused all gentle suggestions (e.g. to just squeeze a letter in between). He finally, with a bit of help from Omi, got it. And was enormously proud.
So, Sam is a perfectionist. This is related to him not wanting to draw for much of the past year because he couldn't make things come out "right". And I'm torn: I don't ever point out spelling errors unless he asks, but when he specifically asks if it's right? should I lie? I feel like I shouldn't, but pitching the tone of the feedback is tricky.
Frida-wise: she laughed for the first time last night when J. was nuzzling her belly alternating with saying an exaggerated "hi!!". So, like a superstitious pigeon, J. kept nuzzling and calling "hi!!" for the next 15 minutes, during which she "heh heh'd" at random intervals until it wore out (and he kept going for another several minutes of extinction). I'll try to post some video soon...


That is some awesome writing! I'm impressed by Sam's determination, even while my heart goes out to the perfectionist in him. So frustrating - and, as you note, hard to know how to address as a parent. It seems to me like you're taking the right approach.
ReplyDeleteAnd I LOVE the phrase "superstitious pigeon."
Go, Sam! His final effort looks great--as do his earlier efforts, if one weren't seeking perfection. I think my instincts would be like yours--not to lie when he asks specifically, but somehow trying to keep the feedback low-key. I just read an Anne Lamott piece with my students decrying perfectionism as a crippling phenomenon derived from one's desire to protect oneself from more of the kind of hurts the world has doled out to one in the past. I agreed with her about the *potentially* crippling part but not that perfectionism was necessarily a reaction to things that had happened to one, as it seems to me that most of the perfectionists I know (myself included) were born to that tendency...much as what-me-worry types seem to be.
ReplyDelete